10 Surprising Items You Shouldn't Buy Second-Hand

Buying second-hand can be a smart way to save money, reduce waste, and discover unique finds.

Thrift stores, online marketplaces, and garage sales are treasure troves for clothing, furniture, and household goods.

However, not everything should be purchased pre-owned. Some items can pose health risks, safety concerns, or simply won’t hold up well after their first life.

Here are the top items you should avoid buying second-hand.

Disclosure: Simplify may receive a small affiliate commission from purchases made via links in this article but at no cost to you.

1. Mattresses and Bedding

Mattresses are notorious for harboring allergens, bacteria, mold, and even bed bugs. Even if a used mattress looks clean, you can’t be certain about what’s hiding beneath the surface.

Bedding, pillows, and comforters fall into the same category—they can be difficult to sanitize properly and may trigger allergies or skin irritations.

Better option: Buy new for peace of mind, and look for sales or financing options if cost is a concern.

2. Helmets and Safety Gear

Bike helmets, motorcycle helmets, and sports safety gear are designed to absorb impact once.

Even if a helmet looks intact, you can’t be sure it hasn’t been damaged in a crash. Using second-hand safety equipment could compromise your protection.

Better option: Always invest in new safety gear to ensure full effectiveness.

3. Car Seats for Children

Car seats have strict expiration dates due to wear and evolving safety standards.

A used seat might have been in an accident, making it unsafe—even if no damage is visible. Missing instruction manuals or original parts can also affect proper installation.

Better option: Purchase new car seats to guarantee safety and compliance with current regulations.

4. Shoes

Shoes mold to the original owner’s foot shape, meaning used pairs can cause discomfort or even foot problems. Worn-out soles, hidden structural issues, and hygiene concerns make second-hand shoes a risky buy.

Better option: Buy new shoes for proper support and hygiene, but thrift store finds like boots for décor or costume use are fine.

5. Small Kitchen Appliances

Blenders, coffee makers, and toasters may look fine but can have worn wiring or hidden mechanical issues that pose fire hazards. Plus, older models may be less energy-efficient and harder to clean properly.

Better option: Look for refurbished models from reputable retailers if you want to save money safely.

6. Cosmetics and Personal Care Items

Makeup, skincare, and hair tools should never be purchased second-hand.

Opened cosmetics can carry bacteria, leading to skin infections or eye irritations. Items like hairbrushes, razors, and electric toothbrushes are also best avoided due to hygiene concerns.

Better option: Always buy personal care products new, ideally sealed.

7. Tires

Used tires may have uneven wear, unseen punctures, or damage that compromises their safety on the road. Since tire condition directly affects braking and handling, second-hand is rarely worth the risk.

Better option: Invest in new tires from a trusted supplier for guaranteed reliability.

8. Upholstered Furniture

Like mattresses, upholstered couches and chairs can harbor bed bugs, mold, or odors that are nearly impossible to remove. Cleaning and reupholstering can cost more than buying new.

Better option: Stick to second-hand wooden or metal furniture, which can be cleaned and refinished safely.

9. Baby Cribs and Playpens

Older cribs and playpens may not meet modern safety standards. Slat spacing, drop-side designs, and hardware issues make them hazardous. Even well-maintained pieces may have recalls you’re unaware of.

Better option: Buy new or verify with the manufacturer that your crib meets current safety guidelines.

10. Electronics Without Warranty

Second-hand laptops, phones, or TVs can be tempting bargains, but without a warranty, you risk ending up with outdated hardware, battery issues, or devices on their last leg.

Repairs often cost more than buying new.

Better option: Look for certified refurbished electronics from trusted retailers.

Shopping second-hand is a great way to stretch your budget and support sustainability, but some items are worth the splurge to buy new.

Anything that impacts health, hygiene, or safety should never be compromised.

Save your thrifting adventures for clothing, solid wood furniture, books, and décor—and invest in the essentials that keep you and your family safe.