Minimalism Tips: How to Decide What to Keep

Angela | Arrow
by Angela | Arrow

There’s plenty of discussion about decluttering and what to keep in our lives to achieve the basics of minimalism. But there aren't many discussions about the struggle that comes along with how to decide what to keep.


There are plenty of videos out there that discuss what we should not keep, things that make us feel bad, or that are not useful in our lives.

Decluttering

Typical clutter

But we can’t get rid of everything. We are constantly deciding what to keep and let go of. Clutter becomes clutter when it becomes a burden on our lives. Everyone has a different tolerance level.


Once we feel overwhelmed, we are ready to declutter. We continue discarding, selling, and donating the things that are no longer useful in our lives until we reach what I like to call a minimalism plateau.


It’s the point between knowing that you still have more decluttering to do and wondering if you’re taking this minimalism thing too far and regretting some of the decisions you made.

Decluttering

The crib in question

I’m going to share with you a comment that caught me off-guard. It was a response to a decision I made to keep something that was special to me and my family. It was a handmade play kitchen and doll crib.


Here’s what the comment said:

Comment

We decided to keep these items (the crib and play kitchen) so they can be available in the future at the cottage for grandkids. In no way do we intend to push them on our girls.


So what is it about this particular comment that had me stop and think? It was a bit accusatory. It made me feel like a hoarder. But it also made me stop and think about why I chose to keep these two items. It really had to do with thinking about the future. These items will be stored for a while.


But the comment made me wonder if I was sending mixed messages out there. I noted that I was clutching on to things that weren’t necessarily useful.


Then I snapped out of it. This is my life and my decision. What is it about minimalism that makes us think that we keep nothing or everything?

Pot

Enjoying what we keep

My definition of minimalism is that we get rid of the excess so we can truly appreciate the things that we do choose to keep. It’s about being intentional about our choices. I will never tell you to do things exactly the same way I do them.


We have worked very hard to get the inventory down in our home to a very manageable level. It is up to us to determine what we keep. The same goes for you. If things resonate with you, keep them!


I think the reason Marie Kondo’s method is so important is that it helps people pick out the items that are of value to them and to decide what to keep versus what to give away.


It’s important to pull from the pile what to keep versus what to give away. That makes it easy to give things away that do not give you that same feeling, that same spark. Ultimately you have the freedom to keep what you want and get rid of what you don’t want to keep.


Here are my short guidelines on how to approach deciding what to keep:

Cooking

1. Things you use

We are born with all the things we need but there are tools that enhance our lives. For example, if you’re training to become a doctor, then textbooks are your tools.


If you’re a baker, you have plenty of kitchen tools to use. If you are using things that actively enhance your life, make you more productive, and make you more in tune with the gifts and abilities that are inherent in you–then keep them.

Clothes

2. Things that bring you comfort

There are things we have that we enjoy having because they make our lives more comfortable, like a car, a coat for each season, or an extra blanket on the bed.


The key is active use. If you have a car in your garage but you opt to ride a bike, that care is not bringing you comfort.

Decor

3. Things that align with your values and goals

This varies significantly from person to person. We should not judge others on this goal. If an item is important to you because of your values or goals, it’s okay to keep.

Wedding picture

4. Things that you enjoy

These are things that you want to surround yourself with, the items that make you happy when you look at them. There may be things you enjoy keeping around that almost everyone else sees as clutter.


If you enjoy it, you won’t consider it to be clutter. These things may change over time and there will be frequent reconsidering whether you still enjoy the item.

Decluttering
Do you keep things and photos hidden in boxes?

Photo board

Or do you put things and photos in hiding on display instead?


But ask yourself if you still enjoy having this item around. Do you still find value in holding on to it? With time, connection can be lost or fade even with the most sentimental of items.


Do you take it out of its box from time to time to hold it and look at it? Shoving items into a dark storage space and forgetting about them is not usually something you enjoy having in your life.


If you take one thing away from this discussion, let it be this: Give yourself grace in this process because there are no set rules about living as a minimalist. The goal is to be intentional in your choices.

Christmas decorations

What resonates with you? My decisions may change in the future. But that is up to me and my family to discover. The same goes for you.


When you are decluttering and find items that really resonate with you, you don't need to make the perfect decision.


You may keep things that later hold very little value, and you might even wonder why you kept them in the first place, but that's okay.

Decluttering

5. Decluttering clothing

This is all part of the journey. One reason that Marie Kondo's approach is intuitive is that it is actually much easier for people to pick out the items that are of value for them.


It’s easier to make a decision based on what you want to keep rather than what to get rid of. By setting out all of the things in a specific category, say clothing for example, a person can very easily choose their top favorites that spark joy, as she would say, and pull them from the pile to keep.


Minimalism: How to decide what to keep

Those are my short guidelines about the basics of minimalism and what you might consider keeping and why.


Ultimately, you have the freedom to keep the things that you want to keep and get rid of the things that you don't.


Let me know in the comments how you decide what to keep and what not to keep in your home.

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 4 comments
  • Judy Judy on Oct 21, 2023
    I really enjoyed your post. You make it easier to figure out what to keep. It does feel so much better when the house is lighter from having less stuff. Thank you.
  • Alexa Fulton Alexa Fulton on Nov 06, 2023
    Love this post! Your insights really helped take some of my stress away from decluttering! Thank you for reminding me that what I keep or purge is ultimately MY choice, and also that these decisions don’t have to be instantaneous or final. What’s important is that I’m making progress and feeling good in my space. Thank you!
Next